Michigan’s Supreme Court on November 20, 2026, declined to hear an appeal from more than 70 townships and counties challenging how state regulators apply Public Act 233, the 2023 law that lets the state approve large solar, wind and storage projects. The court will hear arguments in January 2027 on one narrower deadline question.
Key points
- The Supreme Court denied the local governments’ application for leave to appeal a May 7, 2026, Michigan Court of Appeals decision.
- The court ordered oral argument in its January 2027 session on cross-appeals about a 30-day deadline for local officials to respond to developers.
- Briefs are due December 11, 2026, responses December 28, 2026, and replies January 4, 2027.
- PA 233 covers solar facilities of 50 megawatts or more, wind facilities of 100 megawatts or more, and storage of 50 megawatts and 200 megawatt-hours or more.
- The law took effect on November 29, 2024; the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) set out how it would apply it in an October 10, 2024, order.
What the Michigan Supreme Court decided
The case, In re Implementing Provisions of Public Act 233 of 2023, began when local governments challenged the MPSC’s October 2024 order. On the townships’ application, the order says the justices were “not persuaded” the question should be reviewed by the court. All other requests for leave were also denied.
The court did agree to hear arguments on cross-appeals filed by the parties defending the MPSC order. Besides the commission, they include the Michigan Energy Innovation Business Council, the Institute for Energy Innovation, Clean Grid Alliance and Advanced Energy United. The order lists no dissents.
The 30-day question the court will hear
Under PA 233, a developer can apply to the MPSC when a community does not have a “compatible renewable energy ordinance” (CREO), meaning local rules no more restrictive than the standards listed in the law. The statute gives a community’s chief elected official 30 days after a meeting with the developer to say such an ordinance exists. The MPSC started that clock when the community received the developer’s offer to meet; after 30 days without notice, the developer could treat the community as having no CREO. The Court of Appeals held that the clock starts only with the actual meeting.
The justices want briefing on three points: whether the appeals court gave the commission’s interpretation the respectful consideration Michigan precedent requires, whether reversing it was an error, and, alternatively, whether another reading should govern when a meeting never happens or is unreasonably delayed. Argument is set at 40 minutes, split evenly between the two sides.
What the Court of Appeals ruled
In its published May 7, 2026, opinion, a three-judge Court of Appeals panel (Chief Judge Gadola and Judges Murray and Kelly, in an opinion by Judge Murray) held that the MPSC read PA 233 correctly in most respects, including its narrow definition of a CREO and its handling of facilities that combine wind, solar and storage. The panel found two errors: the 30-day timeline and the commission’s definition of an “affected local unit,” which the court said the MPSC “improperly expanded.” It also held that the order was not subject to the rulemaking requirements of Michigan’s Administrative Procedures Act. The Supreme Court’s denial leaves the panel’s other holdings in place; only the 30-day ruling is still under review.
Other perspectives
- The townships’ lawyers at Foster Swift Collins & Smith, which filed the application in June 2026 on behalf of 79 townships and counties, called the MPSC’s order an “unlawful rewriting” of PA 233 and argued it limits local zoning control, according to the firm’s June 19, 2026, release.
Why it matters
PA 233 gives developers of large clean energy projects a state route when a community has no compatible ordinance. Under the law as quoted by the Court of Appeals, the state can site solar facilities of 50 megawatts or more, wind facilities of 100 megawatts or more, and storage facilities of 50 megawatts or more with at least 200 megawatt-hours of discharge capability. With the townships’ appeal denied, the MPSC’s narrow reading of what counts as a compatible local ordinance stands. The January argument will decide how quickly a developer can turn to the state when local officials do not respond. For the arguments local opponents often raise, see our overview of arguments against renewable energy.
What’s next
Cross-appellants’ briefs are due December 11, 2026; responses are due December 28, 2026; and replies and supplemental amicus briefs are due January 4, 2027. The case will be argued during the court’s January 2027 session.
Sources
- Order in In re Implementing Provisions of Public Act 233 of 2023, No. 170249 — Michigan Supreme Court, November 20, 2026
- Opinion in In re Implementing Provisions of Public Act 233 of 2023, No. 373259 — Michigan Court of Appeals, May 7, 2026
- 79 Michigan Municipalities Take Fight for Local Zoning Control to State Supreme Court — Foster Swift Collins & Smith, June 19, 2026
We send one email a week. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

