The disadvantages of coal are serious: coal plants emit more than twice as much carbon dioxide per kilowatt-hour as gas plants, their air pollution has been linked to hundreds of thousands of deaths in the United States, mining injures and sickens workers, and burning coal leaves tens of millions of tons of toxic ash every year. Coal still has real advantages, though. It is stored on site and burned on demand, its fuel is cheap, and the U.S. has enough of it for centuries.
Below we explain how much the U.S. and the world still rely on coal, go through eight disadvantages and five advantages with current data, and look at where coal is heading.
How Much Do We Still Use Coal?
Coal is a fossil fuel formed from swamp plants that lived hundreds of millions of years ago (EIA). Power plants burn it to boil water, and the steam spins a turbine connected to a generator.
In 2025, coal produced about 17% of U.S. utility-scale electricity, behind natural gas (about 41%) and nuclear (about 18%), according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). The U.S. mined about 528 million short tons of coal that year (EIA Monthly Energy Review).
Worldwide, coal matters much more. It generated 33.0% of the world’s electricity in 2025, the first year its share fell below one-third, according to the energy think tank Ember. Global coal demand reached a record of about 8.84 billion tonnes in 2025, and the International Energy Agency (IEA) expects another record in 2026, about 8.94 billion tonnes.
Disadvantages of Coal
1. Far more carbon per kilowatt-hour than gas
Burning coal for electricity released about 2.31 pounds of CO2 per kWh in 2023, compared with 0.96 pounds for natural gas, according to EIA. In other words, a kilowatt-hour from coal carries more than twice the carbon of one from gas. Only petroleum, a minor source of U.S. power, was higher (2.46 pounds), and EIA counts wind, solar and hydro as carbon-neutral.
Coal generated about 17% of U.S. electricity in 2025 but was responsible for 826 million metric tons of the country’s 4,904 million metric tons of energy-related CO2 emissions (EIA), or roughly 17% of the total (our own calculation). Because coal still supplies about a third of global power, its emissions are one of the drivers behind many global environmental issues.
2. Air pollution that shortens lives
Coal smoke contains sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), fine particles (PM2.5) and mercury. A study published in Science in 2023 linked fine particles from U.S. coal power plants to about 460,000 deaths among Medicare-age Americans between 1999 and 2020, and found that exposure to coal PM2.5 carried about 2.1 times the mortality risk of PM2.5 from all sources.
Regulation has cut this pollution sharply. Under the Acid Rain Program and the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule, SO2 emissions from covered power plants fell 96% from 1990 to 2023 and NOx fell 90% (EPA). The same study found that coal’s share of PM2.5-related Medicare deaths dropped from 25% before 2009 to 7% after 2012.
Coal plants are also the largest source of human-caused mercury emissions in the U.S. (EPA). After the 2012 Mercury and Air Toxics Standards, power-plant mercury emissions had dropped 86% by 2017; EPA finalized the repeal of parts of the stricter 2024 amendments on February 24, 2026 (EPA MATS page).
3. Dangerous work for miners
Breathing coal and rock dust causes coal workers’ pneumoconiosis, known as black lung. According to NIOSH, about 1 in 10 U.S. underground miners with 25 or more years on the job have black lung, and in central Appalachia the figure reaches as many as 1 in 5, the highest level recorded in 25 years. The most severe form, progressive massive fibrosis, nearly disappeared in the late 1990s and has since made what NIOSH calls an “unprecedented” comeback.
A 2024 federal rule to cut miners’ exposure to silica dust has been on hold: the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals stayed compliance with it on April 11, 2025, and as of April 2026 MSHA was still enforcing the older limits.
Accidents remain a risk too. Eight people died in U.S. coal mines in 2025 and ten in 2024 (MSHA). The worst recent disaster, the 2010 explosion at the Upper Big Branch mine in West Virginia, killed 29 miners; MSHA’s investigation blamed “a pervasive culture that valued production over safety.”
4. Millions of tons of toxic ash
Burning coal leaves ash and scrubber sludge, known as coal combustion residuals. U.S. plants produced about 69 million tons of this waste in 2020 (EPA). Coal ash contains contaminants such as mercury, cadmium, chromium and arsenic, and EPA says many utilities have identified ash placed outside regulated ponds and landfills as the source of detected groundwater contamination (EPA fact sheet).
When ash dams fail, the damage is immediate. On December 22, 2008, a dike at TVA’s Kingston plant in Tennessee broke and released about 5.4 million cubic yards of coal ash into the Emory River and nearby land (TVA). EPA’s federal coal ash rules followed, but deadlines keep moving: in November 2025, EPA proposed giving some unlined ash ponds larger than 40 acres until October 2031 instead of October 2028 to finish closing (EPA).
Do coal plants release more radiation than nuclear plants? Coal and its ash contain small amounts of uranium and thorium. The U.S. Geological Survey found that the radioactivity of typical fly ash is not significantly different from that of building materials such as granite or red brick, and that the maximum dose to people living within 1 km (about 0.6 mile) of a modern plant is perhaps 1% to 5% above natural background radiation. USGS concluded that these elements “should not be sources of alarm.” The real health problem with coal is air pollution, not radiation.
5. Polluted water
Coal plants that scrub their smoke move part of the pollution into wastewater. EPA estimated that its 2024 steam electric rule would cut more than 660 million pounds a year of pollutants such as selenium, mercury, arsenic and nickel from coal plant wastewater (EPA fact sheet), which shows how much was being discharged. In December 2025, EPA finalized a rule extending compliance deadlines for these wastewater limits (EPA).
6. Methane leaking from mines
Coal seams hold methane, which escapes during and after mining. Active and abandoned coal mines produced about 8% of U.S. methane emissions in 2019 (EPA Coalbed Methane Outreach Program). Over 100 years, a ton of methane traps about 28 times as much heat as a ton of CO2 (EPA), so mine methane adds to coal’s climate impact before any coal is burned. Methane is also explosive: it set off the Upper Big Branch disaster.
7. Damaged land and fires that burn for decades
Surface mining, including mountaintop removal in Appalachia, removes large tracts of forest and buries streams; EPA says streams buried under fill are “permanently lost” (EPA). Abandoned mines are a long-term bill: the federal Abandoned Mine Land fund, financed by industry fees, held about $14.2 billion as of September 30, 2025 (OSMRE).
Coal seams can also catch fire underground. OSMRE counted 98 underground mine fires in nine states in 2013 and called that an underestimate (OSMRE). The fire under Centralia, Pennsylvania, started in 1962 and is still spreading; Congress paid $42 million to relocate the town, and 545 homes and businesses were acquired from 1985 to 1991 (Pennsylvania DEP).
8. A finite resource
Coal takes millions of years to form, so EIA classifies it as a nonrenewable energy source (EIA). The U.S. will not run out soon (see the advantages below), but every ton burned is gone for good. We explain the geology in our guide to whether coal is renewable.
Advantages of Coal
1. Power on demand
A coal plant keeps a stockpile of fuel on site and can run day and night regardless of weather, which is why grid operators have long relied on coal for steady “baseload” power. That reliability has limits: during Winter Storm Elliott in December 2022, about 90,500 MW of generation was out at the same time because of unplanned outages, derates and failures to start. Coal made up 12% of the affected units (gas 47%), and across all fuels most failures came from mechanical and electrical problems, freezing and fuel supply issues (FERC and NERC report).
2. Cheap fuel
Coal cost U.S. power plants an average of $2.47 per million Btu in 2024 (EIA Electric Power Annual). Because coal can be stockpiled, existing plants are less exposed to short-term fuel price spikes.
3. Large domestic reserves
The U.S. has about 250 billion short tons of estimated recoverable coal, enough for about 422 years at the 2022 production rate, and held about 22% of the world’s proved reserves at the end of 2021 (EIA). Coal producers reported about 10.6 billion short tons of recoverable reserves at the end of 2024 (EIA Annual Coal Report).
4. Jobs and local revenue
U.S. coal mines employed an average of 44,060 people in 2024, according to the EIA Annual Coal Report. Coal is also an export product: the U.S. exported about 92.7 million short tons of coal in 2025 (EIA).
5. Essential for most of the world’s steel
Metallurgical coal, turned into coke, is still needed to make iron in blast furnaces. This blast furnace and oxygen furnace route produced 69.4% of the world’s crude steel, according to the World Steel Association. The U.S. depends on it less: by the same source’s estimate, about 71% of American steel comes from electric arc furnaces.
Coal Pros and Cons at a Glance
| Advantages of coal | Disadvantages of coal |
|---|---|
| Runs on demand, fuel stored on site | High CO2 per kWh: 2.31 lb vs 0.96 lb for gas |
| Cheap fuel: $2.47 per million Btu (2024) | PM2.5 linked to ~460,000 U.S. deaths (1999–2020) |
| U.S. reserves for about 422 years | Black lung in up to 1 in 5 veteran Appalachian miners |
| 44,060 U.S. mining jobs (2024) | ~69 million tons of coal ash a year (2020) |
| Needed for ~69% of world steel | Wastewater, mine methane (~8% of U.S. methane), damaged land |
Sources: EIA, Science (2023), NIOSH, EPA, World Steel Association, linked above.
Is Coal Good or Bad Overall?
For the climate and public health, coal carries the heaviest burden of the major U.S. power sources covered here: more than twice the CO2 of gas per kilowatt-hour, plus deadly air pollution, toxic waste and mining risk.
For the power grid, existing coal plants still provide reliable capacity, which is why some are being kept open longer than planned. But they are not immune to extreme weather.
For your electricity bill, the fuel itself is cheap, but the health and environmental costs show up elsewhere, in medical bills and cleanup funds. Comparing the pros and cons of wind power or hydropower shows what the alternatives trade off.
For coal communities, the decline means lost jobs and tax revenue, so the pace of the transition and support for workers matter as much as the energy choice itself.
The Future of Coal
In the U.S., coal’s decline has slowed. Only 2.6 GW of coal capacity retired in 2025, the least since 2010, against 8.5 GW that operators had planned at the start of the year, and operators plan to retire 6.4 GW, almost 4% of the fleet, in 2026 (EIA). An April 2025 executive order set out to support the industry, and Department of Energy emergency orders kept several coal plants slated for retirement, including J.H. Campbell in Michigan, available to run (DOE).
Even so, the IEA expects U.S. coal demand to fall about 7% in 2026 after rising in 2025, while global demand sets another record (IEA).
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the biggest disadvantage of coal?
Its effect on health and climate. Coal emits about 2.31 pounds of CO2 per kWh, more than twice as much as natural gas, and fine particles from U.S. coal plants have been linked to about 460,000 deaths between 1999 and 2020.
What are 3 disadvantages of coal?
Three of the most serious are high carbon emissions, air pollution that causes heart and lung disease, and toxic coal ash that can contaminate groundwater. Mining adds black lung disease, accidents and damaged land.
What are the advantages of coal?
Coal plants can run on demand with fuel stored on site, coal is a cheap fuel ($2.47 per million Btu delivered to U.S. plants in 2024), and the U.S. has reserves for about 400 years. Coal is also still needed for most of the world’s steel.
Is coal energy clean?
No. Modern scrubbers and filters remove most sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and mercury, but they do not remove carbon dioxide, and the ash and wastewater they produce still need safe disposal. “Clean coal” usually refers to plants with carbon capture.
Why is coal still used if it is so harmful?
Because many existing plants are paid off and reliable, coal is cheap and abundant, and global demand is still at record levels. In the U.S., coal now supplies about 17% of electricity, behind natural gas and nuclear.
We send one email a week. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.


